This study explores a unique group of narrators from the elder generation of successors (Kib?r al-T?bi??n) who transmitted ?ad?th from three or more Companions (?a??ba) and were deemed "acceptable" (maqb?l) by Ibn ?ajar al-?Asqal?n? in his critical work, Taqr?b al-Tahdh?b. Positioned in the sixth tier of narrator assessment, these individuals highlight the need to examine the relationship between the diversity of sources and the moderate reliability attributed to them in the field of al-jar? wa-al-ta?d?l. Although they had access to multiple Companions—often seen as beneficial for transmission integrity—their limited recognition in authoritative collections and their cautious reliability classification raise important methodological questions. This research fills a gap by systematically identifying, classifying, and analyzing these narrators, focusing on their transmission patterns, volume of narrations, and academic reception in classical sources. A qualitative, inductive-analytical approach is employed, primarily extracting data from Taqr?b al-Tahdh?b and verifying it through biographical dictionaries and ?ad?th anthologies. The study categorizes narrators based on their transmission of Marf?? and Mawq?f reports, the extent of their narrational reach, consistency in biographical identity, and levels of endorsement by Ibn ?ibb?n and other scholars. The findings deepen our understanding of Ibn ?ajar’s methodology for evaluating narrators with extensive but superficial isn?d connections. By clarifying how narrators with three or more Companions remained within the maqb?l category, the research underscores that source diversity alone does not guarantee a higher status in the narrator hierarchy. This work provides valuable insights into early transmission networks and the complex criteria used in narrator authentication, thereby enhancing scholarly engagement with ?ad?th validation frameworks.
Ab? D?w?d, S. I. A. (2009). As-sunan. D?r al-Ris?lah al-??lam?yah.
Ahmad, M. A. B. M. (2003). Those described with the term “maqb?l” in Taqr?b al-Tahdh?b from ?Ulla ibn ?Abd al-Ra?m?n al-Yam?m? to Ab? ??li? al-Ash?ar? [Doctoral dissertation, Imam Muhammad bin Saud Islamic University].
al-Bukh?r?, M. I. (1989). Al-?a??? (2nd ed.). D?r ?awq al-Naj?h.
al-Dhahab?, S. A. (1995). M?z?n al-i?tid?l f? naqd al-rij?l. D?r al-Kutub al-?Ilmiyyah.
al-Dhahab?, S. A. (1967). D?w?n al-?u?af?? wa-al-matr?k?n. Maktabat al-Nah?ah al-?ad?thah.
al-Far?h?d?, A. K. I. A. (2003). Kit?b al-?ayn. D?r al-Kutub al-?Ilmiyyah.
al-Jait?n, M. A. A. (2010). The term “accepted” according to Ibn Hajar and its applications to the narrators in the Four Sunan [Master’s thesis, An-Najah National University].
al-Kha??b al-Baghd?d?, A. (n.d.). Al-kif?yah f? ?ilm al-riw?yah. D?r al-Kutub al-?Ilmiyyah.
al-Mizz?, Y. I. A. A. (1980). Tahdh?b al-kam?l f? asm?? al-rij?l (1st ed.). Mu?assasat ar-Ris?lah.
al-Nawaw?, Y. (2003). Taqr?b al-tahdh?b. D?r al-Kutub al-?Ilmiyyah.
al-Nis???, A. I. S. (1986). Al-mujtab? mina al-sunan (2nd ed.). Maktab al-Ma?b???t al-Isl?miyyah.
al-Nis???, A. I. S. (2001). Al-sunan al-kubr? (1st ed.). Mu?assasat al-Ris?lah.
al-Sakh?w?, S. A. (2005). Fat? al-mugh?th. D?r al-Fikr.
al-Shahr?n?, ?A. B. M. B. S. (2005). Those described with the term “maqb?l” in Taqr?b al-Tahdh?b from ?af? ibn ?Umar ibn Sa?d al-Madani to Sa??d ibn ?Amr al-?a?ram? [Doctoral dissertation, Imam Muhammad bin Saud Islamic University].
al-Shawk?n? As?r?, ?. B. A. B. M. (2002). Those described with the term “maqb?l” in Taqr?b al-Tahdh?b from ?Abdull?h ibn al-??rith ibn Abz? to ?Abdul?Az?z ibn ?Abdulmalik al-Jumah? [Doctoral dissertation, Imam Muhammad bin Saud Islamic University].
al-Shayb?n?, A. I. M. I. H. (2001). Al-musnad (1st ed.). Mu?assasat ar-Ris?lah.
al-Suy???, J. A. (1995). Tadr?b al-r?w? f? shar? Taqr?b al-Nawaw?. D?r al-Kutub al-?Ilmiyyah.
al-Tirmidh?, M. I. (1975). Al-sunan (2nd ed.). D?r al-Kutub al-?Ilmiyyah.
al-Zubayd?, A. M. (n.d.). T?j al-?ar?s min jaw?hir al-q?m?s. Ma?ba?at al-?uk?mah.
al-?Ir?q?, Z. A. (2002). Al-taqy?d wa al-????. D?r Ibn al-Jawz?.
al-??kim al-Nays?b?r?, M. (1977). Ma?rifat ?ul?m al-?ad?th. D?r al-Kutub al-?Ilmiyyah.
Aris, H., & Muslim, N. (2018). The conditions for the term maqb?l for Ibn Hajar in his work Taqr?b al-Tahdh?b. International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences, 8(7), 187–195. https://doi.org/10.6007/IJARBSS/v8-i7/4382
Aris, H., & Muslim, N. (2020). The maqb?l status of al-Bukh?r? and Muslim teachers in Ibn Hajar’s Taqr?b al-Tahdh?b. International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences, 10(9), 660–670. https://doi.org/10.6007/IJARBSS/v10-i9/7736
Hamida, K. (2019). The status of “accepted narrator” in hadith scholarship. Journal of Prophetic Heritage, 3(5), 1–xx.
Ibn ?Abd al-Barr, Y. (2000). Al-tamh?d lim? f? al-muwa??a? min al-ma??n? wa al-as?n?d. D?r al-Gharb al-Isl?m?.
Ibn Ab? ??tim, ?A. I. M. (1952). Al-jar? wa-al-ta?d?l (1st ed.). D?r I?y?? al-Tur?th al-?Arab?.
Ibn ?ajar al-?Asqal?n?, A. I. (1986). Tahdh?b al-tahdh?b. D?r al-Fikr.
Ibn ?ajar al-?Asqal?n?, A. I. (1995). Taqr?b al-tahdh?b. D?r al-Ris?lah al-??lamiyyah.
Ibn ?ajar, A. I. ?A. (1971). Lis?n al-m?z?n (2nd ed.). Mu?assasat al-A?lam? lil-Ma?b???t.
Ibn ?ajar, A. I. ?A. (2008). Nuzhat al-na?ar (2nd ed.). J?mi?at ?aybah.
Ibn ?ibb?n, M. I. ?. (1973). Al-thiq?t (1st ed.). D??irat al-Ma??rif al-?Uthm?n?yah.
Ibn Kath?r, I. I. ?U. (2013). Ikhti??r ?ul?m al-?ad?th (1st ed.). D?r al-Maym?n.
Ibn M?jah, M. I. Y. A. Q. (2009). Al-sunan (1st ed.). D?r al-Ris?lah al-??lam?yah.
Ibn Man??r, M. (1993). Lis?n al-?arab. D?r ??dir.
Ibn al-?al??, ?U. (1986). Muqaddimah f? ?ul?m al-?ad?th. D?r al-Fikr.
Bounama, F., & Al-Halwani, M. I. (2025). Investigating the Narrators from the Senior Tabi’in Class who Narrated from Three or More Companions and were Classified as “Maqbul” by Ibn Hajar in “Taqrib Al-Tahdhib.” International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences, 15(8), 956–979.
Copyright: © 2025 The Author(s)
Published by Knowledge Words Publications (www.kwpublications.com)
This article is published under the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY 4.0) license. Anyone may reproduce, distribute, translate and create derivative works of this article (for both commercial and non-commercial purposes), subject to full attribution to the original publication and authors. The full terms of this license may be seen at: http://creativecommons.org/licences/by/4.0/legalcode
