When it comes to (???????) and (??????? ??????), the matter of (??????) or (??????? ???????) needs to be carefully and thoughtfully studied. This understanding should come from the thoughts of the magnificent sheikhs who recited the Qur'an. We will enumerate the opinions of each group and then choose one of those views because this is a contentious matter, on which there are differing perspectives. These results from the inaccessibility of historical documents that address this issue. Considering that, this issue is covered by the decisions on (????? ???????) and (????? ???????), Moreover, this is not such issue that the earlier Tajwid specialists looked into in-depth or discussed in their own books. Similar to terminology, opinions on this matter varied amongst earlier specialists, leading to variations in contemporary scholars' comprehension of this concept. As a result, this understanding led to measuring (??????? ??????) over the real (by not just entirely) relying on the Makhraj (Point of Articulation of Letters). This led to the following: the statement of the spacing between two lips (narrow opening) that Sheikh Amir Othman pursued, and from it emerged the contradictory statements of the hadith scholars on the issue of (??????) in (??????? ??????) and (???????) two different views, one of those who said of (???????) and one of those who said of (??????), These two groups based their claims on their respective schools of recitation and reception. However, this case study presents a challenge to the research project, which attempts to present historical references discussing the pronunciation of (??????? ??????) and (???????). The terminology used by early scholars was also intended to be understood and explained, as was Sheikh Amir Othman's view on this matter. The most accurate opinion will be determined by listing all available evidences. The analytical method used in this article study, the terms (??????? ??????) and (???????) in ancient references and defines them based on the definitions of some modern and past scholars. It then explains what these scholars and knowledge seekers have to say about the issue and which they prefer, listing the evidence that supports their opinion. This article reveals that the basic idea behind (??????? ??????) and (???????) is to keep your lips sealed. Additionally, the majority of the predecessor's statements support (???????), and there is no evidence of (???????) in their references. The idea of (??????? ??????) refers to a slight closure that depends on the Makhraj rather than the separation of the lips. Furthermore, the reception is not through (????????) but through (???????). The recitations of the reciters that have been broadcasted on the radio in the past are through (???????). It has been mentioned that Sheikh Amir Othman (may Allah have mercy on him) was the first to announce (??????) in the contemporary era. Moreover, Sheikh Amir Othman himself withdrew the declaration of (??????) in the final days of his life.
The Holy Qur'an
Ibn Al-Badhash, A. A. A. K. G. (1999). “Al-Iqna fil-Qira'at Al-Sab'e”. Edited by: Ahmed Farid Al-Mazid”. Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah.
Ibn al-Jazari, M. M. Y. (2013). “Al-Nashr fil-Qira'at al-Ashr”. Edited by: Al-Saalim Muhammad Mahmoud Al-Shanqeeti. Al-Madinah Al-Munawwarah: King Fahd Complex for the Printing of the Noble Qur'an.
Ibn al-Jazari, M. M. Y. (2015). “Muqaddimah al-Jazariyyah fi-ma Yajib Ala Qari al-Qur'an an Yu'alimah”. Edited by: Muhammad Tamim Al-Zoubi. Al Madinah Al Munawwarah: Alif Lam Meem Technology Foundation.
Ibn al-Jazari, M. M. Y. (2001). “Al-Tamhid fi Ilm al-Tajwid”. Edited by: Ghanim Qudouri Hamd. Beirut: Al-Risalah Foundation.
Ibn al-Jazari, M. M. Y. (2011). “Taqrib Al-Nashr fil-Qira'at al-Ashr. Edited by: Adil Ibrahim Muhammad Rifa'i. Al-Madinah Al-Munawwarah: King Fahd Complex for the Printing of the Noble Qur'an.
Ibn Sayyidah, A. I. (2000). “Al-Mohkam Walmuhit al-Azam”. Edited by: Abdul Hamid Hindawi. Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah.
Ibn Ghalboun, T. M. (1991). “Al-Tazkirah fil-Qira'at al-Thamaan”. Edited by: Ayman Rushdi Suwayd. Jeddah: Charitable Society for Memorizing the Holy Quran.
Ibn Manzur, M. M. A. (1993). “Lisan-Al-Arab”. Beirut: Dar Saadir.
Al-Dani, O. S. O. O. (1988). “Al-Tahdid fil-Itqan wal-Tajwid”. Edited by: Ghanim Qudouri Al- Hamd. Baghdad: Maktabah Dar Al-Anbaar.
Al-Dani, O. S. O. O. (2015). “Al-Taisir fil-Qira'at Al-Sab'e -. Edited by: Khalaf Hammoud Saalim Al-Shagdali. Ha'il: Dar Al-Andalus for Publishing and Distribution.
Al-Dani, O. S. O. O. (2003). “Al-Idgham Al-Kabir. Edited by: Abdul Rahman Hassan Al-Arif. Cairo: `Alam al-kutub for Publishing, Distribution and Printing.
Al-Samnoudi, I. A. A. S. (2007). “Jaami' al-Khayrat fi-Tajwid wa-Tahrir Awjoh al-Qira'at”. Compiled by: Yasir Ibrahim Al Mazru'i. Kuwait: Department of Holy Qur'an Affairs at the Ministry of Endowments.
Al-Shatibi, Q. F. K. (2016). “Hirz al-Amani-wa Wajh al-Tihani”. Edited by: Ali ibn Saad Al- Ghamdi Al-Makki. Beirut: Dar Al-Basha'ir Islamic Company.
Al-Safti, H. H. (2005). “Hidayah al-Qur'ra li Wojoub Itbaaq al-Shafatyn ind al-Qalb wal-Ikhfa”. Cairo: Maktabah Awlad Al-Sheikh li-Turath.
Al-Dabba', N. A. M. (1999). “Lighting in the Statement of the principles of Qira’at”. Cairo: Al- Azhari Heritage Library.
Othman, A. S. (1985). “How to recite the Qur'an”. Damascus: Dar Ibn Kathir. Al-Madinah Al- Munawwarah: Dar Al-Turath.
Al-Ghouthani, Y. R. (2016). “Tajweed Science, Theoretical Provisions and Practical Notes”. Damascus: Dar Al-Ghouthani.
Al-Qari, A. S. M. (2012). “Al-Man'h Al-Fikriyyah fi Sharh al-Muqaddimah al-Jazariyyah”. Edited by: Osama Ataya. Damascus: Dar Al-Ghouthani.
Al-Qurtubi, W. M. (2000). “Al-Muwazah fil-Tajwid”. Edited by: Ghanim Qudouri Al-Hamd. Oman: Dar Ammar.
Al-Muradi, H. Q. A. (2008). “Tawdhih al-Maqasid wal-Masalik bi-Sharh Alfiyyah Ibn Malik”. reviewd and Edited by: Abd al-Rahman Ali Suleiman. Cairo: Dar al-Fikr.
Al-Mar'ashi, M. B. (2008). “Johd al-Moqil”. Edited by: Ghanim Qudouri Al-Hamd. Oman: Dar Ammar.
Haridi, A. M., Al-Ghouthani, Y. R., Al-Banna, M. M., Al-Shanqeeti, M. K. (2017). “Masa'il Mukh'tarat fi al-Tajwid wa al-Qira'at”. Riyadh: King Khalid Foundation.
