From Comparative Risk Assessment to Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis and Adaptive Management: A Review

Accorsi, R., Apostolakis, G. E., Zio, E. (1999). Prioritizing stakeholder concerns in environmental risk management. J Risk Res 1999a; 2(1):11–29.
Accorsi, R., Zio, E., Apostolakis, G. E. (1999). Developing utility functions for environmental decision-making. Prog Nucl. Energy 1999b; 34(4):387–411.
Adem Esmail, B., & Geneletti, D. (2018). Multi-criteria decision analysis for nature conservation: A review of 20 years of applications. Methods in Ecology and Evolution, 9(1), 42–53. doi:10.1111/2041-210x.12899
Allison, C., Sidle, R. C., Tait, D. (2004). Application of decision analysis to forest road deactivation in unstable terrain. Environ Manage 2004; 33:173–85.
Al-Rashdan, D., Al-Kloub, B., Dean, A., Al-Shemmeri, T. T. (1999). Environmental impact assessment and ranking the environmental projects in Jordan. Eur J Oper Res 1999; 18:30–45.
Andrews, C. J., Apul, D. S., Linkov, I. (2004). Comparative risk assessment: experience, current trends, and future directions. In: Linkov I, Ramadan A, editors. Comparative Risk Assessment and Environmental Decision Making. Amsterdam: Kluwer.
Apostolakis, G. E. (2001). Expert judgment resolution in technically-intensive policy disputes. In: Linkov I, Palma-Oliveira J, editors. Assessment and management of environmental risks: cost-efficient methods and applications. Proceedings of the NATO Advanced Research Workshop Boston, MA, USA: Kluwer Academic Publishers. p. 211–20.
Arvai, J., Gregory, R. (2003). Testing alternative decision approaches for identifying cleanup priorities at contaminated sites. Environ Sci Technol 2003; 37(8):1469–76.
Barzilai, J. (2004). Notes on utility theory. In Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics (pp. 1000–1005). The Hague, Netherlands, 10–13 October.
Bearlin, A. R., Schreiber, E. S. G., Nicol, S. J., Starfield, A. M., Todd, C. R. (2002). Identifying the weakest link: simulating adaptive management of the reintroduction of a threatened fish. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 2002; 59:1709–16.
Bella, A., Duckstein, L., Szidarovszky, F. (1996). A multicriteria analysis of the water allocation conflict in the upper Rio Grande River basin. Appl Math Comput 1996; 77:245–65.
Belton, V., Stewart, T. (2002). Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis: an integrated approach. Boston, MA, USA: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Bonano, E. J., Apostolakis, G. E., Salter, P. F., Ghassemi, A., Jennings, S. (2000). Application of risk assessment and decision analysis to evaluate, rank, and select environmental remediation alternatives. J Hazard Mater 2000; 71:35–57.
Borsuk, M., Clemen, R. L., Maguire, L. A., Reckhow, K. (2001). Stakeholder values and scientific modelling in the Neuse River watershed. Group Decis Negot 2001; 10:355–73.
Bridges, T., Kiker, G., Cura, J., Apul, D., Linkov, I. (2005). Towards using comparative risk assessment to manage contaminated sediments. In: Levner E, Linkov I, Proth JM, editors. Strategic Management of Marine Ecosystems. Amsterdam: Springer.
Brown, K., Adger, N. W., Tompkins, E., Bacon, P., Shim, D., Young, K. (2001). Trade-off analysis for marine protected area management. Ecol Econ 2001; 37:417–34.
Bunch, M. J., Dudycha, D. J. (2004). Linking conceptual and simulation models of the Cooum River: collaborative development of a GIS-based DSS for environmental management. Comput Environ Urban Syst 2004; 28:247–64.
Bundy, A. (2004). The ecological effects of fishing and implications for coastal management in San Miguel Bay, the Philippines. Coast Manage 2004; 32:25–38.
Chen, Z., Li, H., Ren, H., Qian, X., and Ju, H. (2011). A Total Environmental Risk Assessment Model for International Hub Airports. International Journal of Project Management; 29, 856-866.
Cinelli, M., Gonzalez, M. A., Ford, R., McKernan, J., Corrente, S., Kadzi?ski, M., & S?owi?ski, R. (2021). Supporting contaminated sites management with Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis: Demonstration of a regulation-consistent approach. Journal of Cleaner Production, 316,128347. doi: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.128347
Dallmeier, F., Alonso, A., Jones, M. (2002). Planning an adaptive management process for biodiversity conservation and resource development in the Camisea River basin. Environ Monit Assess 2002; 76(1):1–17.
Doley, T. M., Benelmoouffok, D., Deschaine, L. M. (2001). Decision support for optimal watershed load allocation. Paper presented at the Society for Modeling and Simulation International Conference Seattle, USA.
Duda, A., Sherman, K. (2002). A new imperative for improving the management of large marine ecosystems. Ocean Coast Manag 2002; 45:797–833.
Fernandes, L., Ridgley, M., van't, Hof. T. (1999). Multiple criteria analysis integrates economic, ecological and social objectives for coral reef managers. Coral Reefs 1999; 18(4):393–402.
Gallego, E., Jiménez, A., Mateos, A., Sazykina, T., Ríos-Insua, S. (2004). Application of Multiattribute Analysis (MAA) to search for optimum remedial strategies for contaminated lakes with the MOIRA system. Paper presented at the 11th annual meeting of the International Radiation Protection Association; Madrid, Spain, May 23–28.
Ganoulis, J. (2003). Evaluating alternative strategies for wastewater recycling and reuse in the Mediterranean area. Water Sci Technol Water Supply 2003; 3(4): 11–9.
Gentile, J. H., Harwell, M. A., Cropper, Jr. W., Harwell, C. C., DeAngelis, D., Davis, S. (2001). Ecological conceptual models: a framework and case study on ecosystem management for South Florida sustainability. Sci Tot Environ 2001; 274:231–53.
Georgopoulou, E., Sarafidis, Y., Diakoulaki, D. (1998). Design and implementation of a group DSS for sustaining renewable energy exploitation. Eur J Oper Res 1998; 109:483–500.
Gregory, R., Failing, L. (2002). Using decision analysis to encourage sound deliberation: water use planning in British Columbia, Canada. Professional practice; p. 492–9.
Gregory, R., Wellman, K. (2001). Bringing stakeholder values into environmental policy choices: a community-based estuary case study. Ecol Econ 2001; 39:37–52.
Grelk, B. J. (1997). A CERCLA-based decision support system for environmental remediation strategy selection. Department of the Air Force, Air Force Institute of Technology.
Grelk, B., Kloeber, J. M., Jackson, J. A., Deckro, R. F., Parnell, G. S. (1998). Quantifying CERCLA using site decision-maker values. Remediation 1998; 8(2):87–105.
Gurocak, E. R., Whittlesey, N. K. (1998). Multiple criteria decision making: a case study of the Columbia River salmon recovery plan. Environ Resour Econ 1998; 12 (4):479–95.
Habron, G. (2003). Role of adaptive management for watershed councils. Environ Manage 2003; 3(11):29–41.
Hämäläinen, R. P., Kettunen, E., Ehtamo, H., Marttunen, M. (2001). Evaluating a framework for multi-stakeholder decision support in water resources management. Group Decis Negot 2001; 10(4):331–53.
Haney, A., Power, R. L. (1996). Adaptive management for sound ecosystem management. Environ Manage 1996; 20(6):879–86.
Herath, G. (2004). Incorporating community objectives in improved wetland management: the use of the analytic hierarchy process. J Environ Manag 2004; 70 (3):263–73.
Hilborn, R., Sibert, J. (1988). Adaptive management of developing fisheries. Mar Policy 1988; 12:112–21.
Hillman, M., Brierly, G. (2002). Information needs for environmental flow allocation: a case study from the Lachlan River, New south wales, Australia. Ann Assoc Am Geogr 2002; 92:617–30.
Huang, I., Keisler, J., and Linkov, I. (2011). Multi-criteria decision analysis in environmental sciences: Ten years of applications and trends. Science of The Total Environment, 409(19), pp.3578-3594.
Joerin, F., Musy, A. (2000). Land management with GIS and multicriteria analysis. Int Trans Oper Res 2000; 7:67–78.
Johnson, B. L. (1999). Introduction to the special feature: adaptive management — scientifically sound, socially challenged? Conserv Ecol 1999; 3(1):10.
Johnson, F., Williams, K. (1999). Protocol, and practice in the adaptive management of waterfowl harvests. Conserv Ecol 1999; 3(1):8.
Joubert, A. R., Leiman, A., de Klerk, H. M., Katua, S., Aggenbach, J. C. (1997). Fynbos (fine bush) vegetation and the supply of water: a comparison of multicriteria decision analysis and cost-benefit analysis. Ecol Econ 1997; 22:123–40.
Kangas, J., Kangas, A., Leskinen, P., Pykalainen, J. (2001). MCDM methods in strategic planning of forestry on state-owned lands in Finland: applications and experiences. J Multi Criteria Decis Anal 2001; 10:257–71.
Khadam, I. M., & Kaluarachchi, J. J. (2003). Multi-criteria decision analysis with probabilistic risk assessment for the management of contaminated ground water. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 23(6), 683–721. doi:10.1016/s0195-9255(03)00117-3
Kholghi, M. (2001). Multi-criterion decision-making tools for wastewater planning management. J Agric Sci Technol 2001; 3:281–6.
Kiker, C, F., Milon, J. W., Hodges, A. W. (2001). Adaptive learning for science-based policy: the Everglades restoration. Ecol Econ 2001; 37:403–16.
Kiker, G. A., Bridges, T. S., Varghese, A., Seager, T. P., & Linkov, I. (2005). Application of Multicriteria Decision Analysis in Environmental Decision Making. Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management, 1(2), 95. doi:10.1897/ieam_2004a-015.1
Klauer, B., Drechsler, M., Messner, F. (2002). Multi-criteria analysis more under uncertainty with IANUS — method and empirical results. UFZ discussion GmbH. Germany: Leipzig; 2002.
Kwak, S. J., Yoo, S. H., Kim, T. Y. (2001). A constructive approach to air-quality valuation in Korea. Ecol Econ 2001; 38:327–44.
Levy, J., Hipel, K., Kilgour, D. M. (2000). Using environmental indicators to quantify the robustness of policy alternatives to uncertainty. Ecol Model 2000; 130: 79–86.
Linkov, I., Satterstrom, F. K., Kiker, G., Batchelor, C., Bridges, T., & Ferguson, E. (2006). From comparative risk assessment to multi-criteria decision analysis and adaptive management: Recent developments and applications. Environment International, 32(8), 1072–1093.
Linkov, I., Satterstrom, F. K., Kiker, G., Seager, T. P., Bridges, T., Gardner, K. H., Meyer, A. (2006). Multicriteria Decision Analysis: A Comprehensive Decision Approach for Management of Contaminated Sediments. Risk Analysis 26(1), 61–78. doi:10.1111/j.1539-6924.2006. 00713.x
Linkov, I., Varghese, A., Jamil, S., Seager, T. P., Kiker, G., Bridges, T. (2004). Multi-criteria decision analysis: a framework for applications in remedial planning for contaminated sites. In: Linkov I, Ramadan A, editors. Comparative Risk Assessment and Environmental Decision Making. Amsterdam: Kluwer; 2004. p. 15–54.
Linkov, I., Varghese, A., Jamil, S., Seager, T. P., Kiker, G., & Bridges, T. (n.d.). Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis: A Framework for Structuring Remedial Decisions at Contaminated Sites. Comparative Risk Assessment and Environmental Decision Making, 15–54. doi:10.1007/1-4020-2243-3_2
Lowry, T. S, Bright JC, Close ME, Robb CA, White PA, Cameron SG. (2003). Management gaps analysis: a case study of groundwater resource management in New Zealand. Water Resour Dev 2003; 19:579–92.
Mardle, S., Pascoe, S., & Herrero, I. (2004). Management objective importance in fisheries: An evaluation using the analytic hierarchy process (AHP). Environmental Management, 33(1), 1–11.
Mardle, S., & Pascoe, S. (2002). Modeling the effects of trade-offs between long and short-term objectives in fisheries management. Journal of Environmental Management, 65, 49–62.
Marmorek, D., & Peters, C. (2001). Finding a PATH toward scientific collaboration: Insights from the Columbia River Basin. Conservation Ecology, 5(2), 8.
Marttunen, M., & Hämäläinen, R. P. (1995). Decision analysis interviews in environmental impact assessment. European Journal of Operational Research, 87(3), 551–563.
McDaniels, T. (1999). A decision analysis of the Tatshenshini-Alsek Wilderness Preservation alternatives. Journal of Environmental Management, 19(3), 498–510.
McDaniels, T. L., & Gregory, R. (2004). Learning as an objective within a structured risk management decision process. Environmental Science & Technology, 38, 1921–1926.
McGinley, K., & Finegan, B. (2003). The ecological sustainability of tropical forest management: Evaluation of the national forest management standards of Costa Rica and Nicaragua, with emphasis on the need for adaptive management. Forest Policy and Economics, 5(4), 421–431.
Mendoza, G. A., Anderson, A. B., & Gertner, G. Z. (2002). Integrating multicriteria analysis and GIS for land condition assessment: Part 2—allocation of military training areas. GIDA, 6(1), 17–30.
Merritt, M. (2001). Strategic plan for salmon research in the Kuskokwim River drainage. Special Publication, Vol. 01-07. Alaska Department of Fish and Game, Division of Sport Fish.
Mimi, Z. A., & Sawalhi, B. I. (2003). A decision tool for allocating the waters of the Jordan River Basin between all riparian parties. Water Resources Management, 17, 447–461.
Ni, J. R., Borthwick, A. G. L., & Qin, H. P. (2002). An integrated approach to determining post-reclamation coastlines. Journal of Environmental Engineering, 128(6), 543–551.
Ning, S. K., & Chang, N. (2002). Multi-objective, decision-based assessment of a water quality monitoring network in a river system. Journal of Environmental Monitoring, 4, 121–126.
Norton, B. G., & Steinemann, A. C. (2001). Environmental values and adaptive management. Environmental Values, 10(4), 473–506.
Nudds, T., Jiao, Y., Crawford, S., Reid, K., McCann, Yang, W. (2003). The DAAM Project—Decision Analysis and Adaptive Management (DAAM) Systems for Great Lakes Fisheries: The Lake Erie Walleye and Yellow Perch Fisheries Project Background and Work Plan.
ODPM (Office of the Deputy Prime Minister). (2004). DLTR multi-criteria decision analysis manual.
Özelkan, E. C., & Duckstein, L. (1996). Analyzing water resources alternatives and handling criteria by multi criterion decision techniques. Journal of Environmental Management, 48(1), 69–96.
Parnell, G. S., Frimpon, M., Barnes, J., Kloeber Jr, J. M., Deckro, R. F., & Jackson, J. A. (2001). Safety risk analysis of innovative environmental technology. Risk Analysis, 21(1), 143–155.
Pavlou, S. P., & Stansbury, J. S. (1998). Risk-cost trade off considerations for contaminated sediment disposal. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment, 4(4), 991–1002.
Pinkerton, E. (1999). Factors in overcoming barriers to implementing co-management in British Columbia salmon fisheries. Conservation Ecology, 3(2), 2.
Prato, T. (2003). Multiple attribute evaluation of ecosystem management for the Missouri River. Ecological Economics, 45, 297–309.
Qin, H. P., Ni, J. R., & Borthwick, A. G. L. (2002). Harmonized optimal post-reclamation coastline for Deep Bay, China. Journal of Environmental Engineering, 128(6), 552–561.
Ríos-Insua, S., Gallego, E., Mateos, A., & Jiménez, A. (2002). A decision support system for ranking countermeasures for radionuclide contaminated aquatic ecosystems: The MOIRA project. pp. 283–297.
Rogers, S. H., Seager, T. P., & Gardner, K. H. (2004). Combining expert judgment and stakeholder values with Promethee: A case study in contaminated sediments management. In I. Linkov & A. Bakr Ramadan (Eds.), Comparative Risk Assessment and Environmental Decision Making (pp. 305–322). Boston, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Salafsky, N., Margoluis, R., Redford, K. H., & Robinson, J. G. (2002). Improving the practice of conservation: A conceptual framework and research agenda for conservation science. Conservation Biology.
Satterstrom, K., Linkov, I., Kiker, G., Ferguson, E., & Bridges, T. (2006). Multi-criteria decision analysis and adaptive management: A review and framework for application to superfund sites. In G. P. Macey & J. Cannon (Eds.), Reclaiming the Land: Rethinking Superfund Institutions, Methods, and Practices. Springer.
Schmoldt, D., Mendoza, G. A., & Kangas, J. (2001). Past developments and future directions for the AHP in natural resources. The Analytic Hierarchy Process in Natural Resource and Environmental Decision Making, 289–305.
Schmoldt, D., Peterson, D., & Silsbee, D. (1994). Developing inventory and monitoring programs based on multiple objectives. Environmental Management, 18(5), 707–727.
Seager, T. P. (2004). Understanding industrial ecology and the multiple dimensions of sustainability. In O'Brien, Gere Engineers (Eds.), Strategic Environmental Management. New York, NY: John Wiley and Sons.
Sharifi, M. A., Van Den Toorn, W., & Emmanuel, M. (2002). International Institute for Geoinformation Science and Earth Observation.
Sit, V., & Taylor, B. (Eds.). (1998). Statistical Methods for Adaptive Management Studies. Land Management Handbook. British Columbia Ministry of Forests Research Program.
Sidra, G., Ghori, R. A., Memon, M. A., Pathan, G. N., Surahio, M. K., & Shaikh, E. A. (2025). Occupational exposure and physiological risk perception among workers in the textile sector: A cross sectional study from Hyderabad, Pakistan.
Soma, K. (2003). How to involve stakeholders in fisheries management—A country case study in Trinidad and Tobago. Marine Policy, 27, 47–58.
Sparrevik, M., Barton, D. N., Bates, M. E., & Linkov, I. (2012). Use of stochastic multi-criteria decision analysis to support sustainable management of contaminated sediments. Environmental Science & Technology, 46(3), 1326–1334. https://doi.org/10.1021/es202225x
Stansbury, J., Bogardi, I., & Stakhiv, E. Z. (1999). Risk-cost optimization under uncertainty for dredged material disposal. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, 125(6), 342–351.
Tal, A., & Linkov, I. (2004). The role of comparative risk assessment in addressing environmental security in the Middle East. Risk Analysis, 24, 1243.
Topuz, E., Talinali, I., & Aydin, E. (2011). Integration of environmental and human health risk assessment for industries using hazardous materials: A quantitative multi-criteria approach for environmental decision makers. Environment International, 37, 393–403.
Tran, L., Knight, C. G., O’Neill, R., Smith, E., Ritters, K., & Wickham, J. (2002). Environmental assessment fuzzy decision analysis for integrated environmental vulnerability assessment of the mid-Atlantic region. Environmental Management, 29(6), 845–859.
Vaillancourt, K., & Waaub, J. P. (2002). Environmental site evaluation of waste management facilities embedded into EUGENE model: A multicriteria approach. European Journal of Operational Research, 139, 436–448.
Van Damme, L., Russell, J. S., Doyon, F., Duinker, P. N., Gooding, T., Hirsch, K., et al. (2003). The development and application of a decision support system for sustainable forest management on the Boreal Plain. Journal of Environmental Engineering and Science, 2, S23–S24.
Van Moeffaert, D. (2002). Multi-Criteria Decision Aid in Sustainable Urban Water Management. Stockholm, Sweden: Royal Institute of Technology.
Van Staden, V., Erasmus, B. F. N., Roux, J., Wingfield, M. J., & van Jaarsveld, A. S. (2004).
Modelling the spatial distribution of two important South African plantation forestry pathogens. Forest Ecology and Management, 187, 61–73.
Voss, M. (2000). The Central and Southern Florida Project comprehensive review study: Restoring the Everglades. Ecology Law Quarterly, 27, 751–770.
Wakeman, J. B. (2003). Decision analysis based upon implementability of the action alternatives at Milltown Dam.
Weinstein, M. P., Balletto, J. H., Teal, J. M., & Ludwig, D. F. (1997). Success criteria and adaptive management for a large-scale wetland restoration project. Wetlands Ecology and Management, 4, 111–127.
Shaikh, T. Z., Ghori, R. A., Humaira, M., Shah, S. N., Memon, H. N. A., Ghori, U. A., & Ghori, S. (2017). Frequency and source of infection in patients with sepsis. Indo American Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences, 4(10).
Ghori, R. A., Shaikh, T. Z., Humaira, M., Shah, S. N., et al. (2017). Demographical and clinical profile of patients with various hematological disorders. Indo American Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences.
Weishar, L. L., & Teal, J. M. (1998). The role of adaptive management in the restoration of degraded diked salt hay farm wetlands. Proceedings of the ASCE Wetlands Engineering & River Restoration Conference, Denver, CO.
Ghori, S., Ghori, R. A., Mohsin Shaikh, Surahio, M. K., & Shaikh, E. A. (2025). Evaluating case-based learning in physiology: A study at Indus Medical College. Journal of Medical and Health Studies.
Whitaker, K., & Focht, W. (2001). Expert modeling of environmental impacts. Oklahoma Politics, 10, 179–186.
Wilhere, G. F. (2002). Adaptive management in habitat conservation plans. Conservation Biology, 16, 20–29.
Wladis, D., Rosén, L., & Kros, H. (1999). Risk-based decision analysis of atmospheric emission alternatives to reduce groundwater degradation on the European scale. Ground Water, 37(6), 818–826.
Wu, K., & Zhang, L. (2014). Progress in the development of environmental risk assessment as a tool for the decision-making process. Journal of Service Science and Management, 7(2), 131–143.
Yatsalo, B., Sullivan, T., Didenko, V., Gritsuk, S., Tkachuk, A., Mireabasov, O., & Linkov, I. (2012). Environmental risk management with the use of multi-criteria spatial decision support system DECERNS. International Journal of Risk Assessment and Management, 16(4), 175. https://doi.org/10.1504/ijram.2012.051254
Yoe, C. (2002). Trade-off analysis planning and procedures guidebook. Prepared for Institute for Water Resources, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.
Ghori, S., Ghori, R., Surahio, M. K., & Shaikh, E. (2025). Risk management and risk assessment in physiology: Analysis of modern developments on their foundation. International Journal of Academic Research in Progressive Education and Development, 14(3), 2226–6348. https://doi.org/10.6007/IJARPED/v14-i3/25698
Ghori, S., Rafi, A. G., Shaikh, M. A., Surahio, M. K., & Shaikh, E. A. (2025). Occupational exposure and physiological risk perception among workers in the textile sector: A cross-sectional study from Hyderabad, Pakistan. Journal of Medical and Health Studies.
Ghori, S., Surahio, M. K., Shaikh, M. A., & Shaikh, E. A. (2025). The role of clinical exercise physiologists in reducing the burden of chronic disease in Pakistan. International Journal of Academic Research in Progressive Education and Development, 14(3). http://dx.doi.org/10.6007/IJARPED/v14-i3/25945

Ghori, S., Ghori, R. A., Shaikh, M. A., Surahio, M. K., & Ali, E. (2025). From Comparative Risk Assessment to Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis and Adaptive Management: A Review. International Journal of Academic Research in Psychology, 12(1), 1–19.

Copyright: © 2025 The Author(s)
Published by Knowledge Words Publications (www.kwpublications.com)
This article is published under the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY 4.0) license. Anyone may reproduce, distribute, translate and create derivative works of this article (for both commercial and non-commercial purposes), subject to full attribution to the original publication and authors. The full terms of this license may be seen at: http://creativecommons.org/licences/by/4.0/legalcode